Subtitles by OnDemandKorea
I was just kidding.
I was only kidding.
While you thought it was a joke,
do you remember how the victims were acting?
Do you remember their faces, their words?
Did they enjoy it as much as you did?
Did they laugh like you?
Did they ever scream that it hurts?
Beg you to stop?
Didn't they protest in tears?
You're right, you're falsely accused.
It was done by a false letter of accusation and a biased media report.
Then!
Why did that happen?
Isn't it because of the hatred of the students who'd rather lie to get you out
of this school?
You continued to ridicule, criticize, belittle, verbal and physical violence!
The result of your wrongdoings
put you in this position. Don't you think?
Stop it.
Have you ever tried to understand the victims? Even once?
You trampled all over others' dignity and personal rights,
yet so confident with your family's wealth as your shield.
Can you understand what it feels like to watch you being that way
I told you to stop!
Who, why, and how the letter of accusation was written are just issues on surface.
It could've been anyone in this school to trap the defendant.
It's a brutal lie with ill intention.
But the letter of accusation was a form of self-defense.
I'll finish my examination here.
I'm sorry.
No, no, no!
Who says the letter's a lie?
I saw it, I saw it!
I saw Choi Woo-hyuk curse So-woo and push him off the roof!
You have evidence, that sound!
That sound on the ledge, I heard it because I was there.
Otherwise it can't be explained, right?
It's because you heard it when you went up there, not Lee So-woo.
No.
No, no! I saw it!
Choi Woo-hyuk is a murderer! He should never be forgiven!
Don't ask for pity like that. You need to die!
A person like you should just die! You must never be forgiven!
I'm sorry.
I'm so sorry.
I'm sorry!
Joo-ri!
To the nurse's office!
I saw it.
That night...
It's true, I saw someone on the rooftop while I was taking a walk.
so I came to the school building, and saw someone running away.
This is the truth.
Get some rest.
Isn't it a little sad though?
They reap what they sow.
When the jury goes into deliberation, how long do they take to decide?
Probably by tomorrow. I guess this is how it ends.
I knew Lee So-woo killed himself.
The school trial is just to get some attention.
Don't be so mean! It was so interesting.
(Jury Discussion No outside person may enter)
I understand.
Thank you for your hard work.
How can he be so cold?
He asked me how Choi Woo-hyuk acted with the students in school.
So I did some research and told him, and he totally used it against him!
I thought he was preparing for another victim to testify.
I had no idea he was gonna do that.
But...
The girl who was locked up in the shower then found in the morning...
It was Lee Joo-ri?
Yes. That's what I heard.
I would've felt the same.
If that ever happened to me,
I would hate him to death, too.
How about you?
Honestly... I agree.
But still! I can't believe she made up a lie to say that he killed someone.
I'm not sure either.
Maybe it's because I wasn't the one who got locked up in the shower.
What can I do to feel better?
Should I just beat you up?
If you want.
Is this why you said things like, "I believe you," "I'm on your side,"
"I'm your defense counsel,"
to flatter me until this point?
Yet deep down inside, you wished for my destruction and for me to suffer?
Because I'm your defense counsel,
I got you off the false accusation of murdering Lee So-woo.
I have no responsibility to cover up all of your wrongdoings.
I never asked you to cover up anything!
You said you were on my side, until the end!
I am on your side, still am.
Then how could you do this to me?
Choi Woo-hyuk.
Cussing out people whenever you want,
screaming, punching,
hurting people at your will...
But not remembering any of those things...
- Doesn't that remind you of someone? - I know.
I'm just like my dad.
But what do you want me to do about that? That's just how I am.
Woo-hyuk.
"I never asked to be born in this family, born in such parents..."
I'm sure it's sad and frustrating,
yet you feel so powerless.
I'm sure you feel like you're the most unlucky person in the world.
But...
Even when it feels like there's not a single choice you can make on your own,
there's one thing.
How you live from now is completely your choice.
You have at least that much hope.
I told you. You still have a chance.
I wish the best for you, as someone who's gone through that pain before.
And as a friend.
Keep your head up. The trial isn't over yet.
We still haven't found out why Lee So-woo died.
(Solomon's Perjury Episode 10)
- I'm leaving for school. - Wait right there!
What happens after jury reaches a verdict?
The judge receives the verdict from the jury,
then he writes the sentencing and reads it in court.
Then...
That's it.
Regardless of the result,
you did such an incredible job in pulling it through this far!
No need to be disappointed, OK?
I'll see you later.
Ko Seo-yeon.
(Lee Joo-ri: I have something to report, I saw a male student run out from school.
He ran towards the stairs.)
A male student that night?
(Lee Joo-ri: I have something to report, I saw a male student run out from school.)
Jeong-guk Watchman sent me this in the morning.
It's a screen capture of the message he received from Joo-ri.
Look at the time stamp.
12:30, Christmas night.
It's before Lee So-woo was found.
Actually,
she told me this in the nurse's office yesterday.
But I couldn't really think straight then.
And...
I was tired of having to decide whether I trust her or not. So I just left.
But this message totally woke me up.
Joo-ri didn't know what was going on at this point.
She hadn't targeted Choi Woo-hyuk then.
She just reported what she saw.
Then...
The male student at the phone booth? He didn't just call So-woo, but came to
school and...
We can't come to a decision yet but it's a possibility.
That's why I really want to check.
Before the trial ends for good.
We still have at least two hours left.
The judge and the jury's meeting hasn't happened yet.
Let's find out until then!
- Hurry! - I'll go with you!
He came out this way...
Then ran up the stairs?
This is far from the gate, and it's a dead end.
Why would he run here?
What if he ran around the whole building and left the opposite way?
He could've jumped over the wall.
He wouldn't purposely pick a longer and harder route to run.
He should've gone straight to the exit.
Maybe he didn't know the way.
I get lost all the time when I go to new places.
He's not from this school?
The store car!
Hey, here!
Hello.
I see you often. I feel like your aunt.
I'm just kidding. I don't want you to get scared because I'm a cop.
That's OK. Please go ahead.
Were you close to Lee So-woo?
No need to be so surprised, it's not a bad thing.
Why did you keep it a secret?
Jeong-guk Watchman is you, isn't it?
No need to exercise your right to be silent. I feel like I'm interrogating you.
I'm sorry.
I didn't know you'd find out so quickly.
Then... You knew that I'd find out at some point?
- Yes. - And you hid it on purpose?
Yes.
Why?
I thought it might get in the way.
In the way of what?
Finding out what happened to So-woo.
So you wanted to find out what happened to So-woo yourself.
Yes.
Then why did you choose to be the defense counsel?
How does helping Choi Woo-hyuk help you?
It was the only way I could take part in the trial.
And...
Choi Woo-hyuk didn't do it to begin with.
Then it's someone else?
Han Ji-hoon.
I'm not sure what your plan is, but
you're not just hiding yourself from people.
You're lying to your friends in the trial club.
Regardless of how justified your reasoning is,
don't you feel bad for them?
Have you thought about how betrayed they'll feel later?
I know. I do.
But can you just wait a little longer?
I'll reveal everything. All of it.
You'll understand me then.
And my friends...
They'll hate me.
But that's OK.
Please, I ask you.
Please wait.
God's helping us!
I'm glad she got in an accident!
Oh, cancel that.
Ko Seo-yeon, you got it, right?
If we don't find anything here, the trial ends as it is. You have to accept it.
Lee Joo-ri... She really saw it!
Then... Who is this guy?
Prosecutors, what do you think you're doing?
Why didn't you pick up your phone?
30 missed calls?
- What is it? - Something important.
Prosecutors request the jury to hold the deliberation process.
Let's extend the trial just one more day.
Seo-yeon.
I didn't think you were like this, but isn't this too cheap?
We proved his alibi.
He's about to be ruled innocent!
Choi Seung-hyun!
Refrain from assuming the verdict.
They must have a good reason.
What is it?
A new piece of evidence.
Someone came to school and ran away at the hour of Lee So-woo's death.
It's just someone running.
Isn't it too far-fetched to say that this is related to the case?
I agree.
It's not just this.
Call records from Lee So-woo's phone in his room that night.
These phone calls were made from pay phones.
Pay phones?
Yes. All five calls.
We did some research, and there's a witness.
The stationery store owner saw something.
He saw a male student talking on the phone, crying.
Don't you see a connection?
Someone is continuously being found around Lee So-woo.
I said it last time.
Let's find out what happened to Lee So-woo.
We haven't found out yet.
We don't know who this guy is, how he's related to Lee So-woo...
Why did he call, and why did he come to school?
If your goal is to find out who this guy is,
are you suggesting a trial without a defendant?
We can approach from different angles, rather than deciding guilty or innocent.
You believe Lee So-woo committed suicide, right?
Yes.
Then you can assert that he committed suicide, and refute my claims and evidence.
We can just continue as we have been, just without a defendant.
What do you guys think?
I thought the trial was going to end.
I came to see the verdict, but what is this?
What are you guys doing?
Let me see.
(Announcing the fourth trial date: The jury's verdict has been postponed.
The trial club voted for a fourth trial date. We thank you for your cooperation.)
What?
- A fourth trial session? - Yes.
They're postponing the verdict and wants to extend another day.
What? That's totally ridiculous!
Isn't Choi Woo-hyuk already found innocent?
Then why extend the trial?
That's what I'm saying.
Yes.
A fourth session?
Got it.
Let's go to Jeong-guk High School.
I'm not even the official principal.
But you want me to give such a serious disciplinary action?
How can I handle the criticism after?
It's according to the school policy. The three trials are enough for expulsion.
But you did agree for the trial, too.
So we lessened the severity.
I never agreed to the trial!
I tried so hard to block it!
How about the chairperson?
Will he approve this haphazard decision?
He's very upset about the applicants' numbers being cut to half.
Mr. Vice Principal.
We did some research in the foundation and found that you've violated
the School Violence Prevention Committee's policies.
But you told me to...
Not only that, you allowed the trial to take place thus the current
trouble in school.
Through this, you seriously damaged the school's name and honor.
We've ruled that you've failed in your management of the school.
It's been a while, Mr. Vice Principal.
Thank you for all your work.
Mr. Han!
A little brighter, more!
This is max.
What is it?
(Cho-rong)
Park Cho-rong?
Cho-rong!
When did you wake up?
Why didn't you tell us? We were so worried!
I didn't want to cause trouble.
You're OK now? How many fingers am I holding up?
Three.
What does the school serve on hot summer days?
Chicken stew and radish.
I'm so glad you're OK!
Cho-rong's back!
Sorry to call you out of the blue.
- Were you shocked? - No, it's OK.
I'm sorry I didn't come to visit so often.
I couldn't have remembered anyways.
Oh, that's right.
You said you liked this bread.
I got them for you.
I still have to watch what I eat.
Sorry.
I should've thought about it more.
Why do you keep saying sorry?
I'm thankful for you, actually.
For all of you.
I saw the trial.
I'm so thankful that you guys were on Joo-ri's side while I was gone.
If it weren't for you,
bad things could've happened to Joo-ri.
Cho-rong!
You don't hate her? This is her fault!
Don't say that.
It was just an accident.
Joo-ri didn't do anything.
I know people think she's so evil and I'm so stupid, that she just
drags me around.
I read all the comments on Jeong-guk Watchman account.
But Joo-ri...
She's a good friend to me.
She goes to watch movies that she doesn't like when I ask her.
We went on a trip together, and she bought me a friendship bracelet.
We have many more fond memories than bad.
But...
I feel like everyone wants me to be the victim.
It makes it easier for them to criticize Joo-ri.
Joo-ri is not how you make her out to be.
I...
Really wanted to tell you this.
Mom?
Mom! Mom!
Are you OK? Do you want some water?
Mom...
That same dream?
Get out of my way!
Mom.
I can't stand it any longer.
How long do I have to live with seeing your face whenever I wake up?
Why do I have to do that? Why?
I'll do it.
I can do it.
What?
I don't need this many clothes. I'll leave some here. subtitles ripped and synced by riri13
What do you think you're doing?
Bae Joon-young! What do you think you're doing?
You should beg for forgiveness!
You're just acting up, aren't you?
Who do you think you are? What gives you the right?
I've done nothing wrong.
You've done nothing wrong?
You're stupid!
- You're worthless! - The reason you're mad at me...
Is not that.
Then what is it?
My older brother.
You...
How can you bring him up with your own mouth?
How can you mention Joon-seok?
Why do you think he turned out that way?
No.
It's not my fault that he died!
How is it not your fault?
He died because of you!
My Joon-seok died because of you!
How's it not your fault?
Stop it, what's going on?
- Let go of me! - Stop it!
He just brought up Joon-seok...
You!
Say it again.
Joon-seok died because he followed you.
I told you not to go, but you took him along and he died!
Joon-seok died, but you lived!
Do you know what I think every time you say things like that?
It's better...
It's better that he's the one who died.
What?
He only got to see your good side.
He didn't have to see through your going mad, or the family's breaking down!
He doesn't need to know.
He has no reason to hate you like I do!
Joon-young!
Bae Joon-young!
How can you say that?
How can you say that you're glad he's dead?
How can you say such a thing?
How dare you!
You're not even human!
How can you say that!
- How can you say that! - Honey, calm down!
Bae Joon-young!
Calm down!
Joon-young!
Please don't be like this, not you.
We agreed to be patient until she gets better.
We agreed to be thankful that she didn't kill herself.
But I want to die!
I almost did.
I stood on the ledge of a rooftop for a while.
I got down because I got scared.
And I was going to jump off when I became ready in a bit.
If she wasn't there for me...
I want to believe that...
I want to believe that everything's going to be OK if I'm just patient.
But it's too hard, Dad.
Joon-young.
I should get you a toothbrush and leave it in my bathroom.
You're hungry?
I'll make you ramen.
You can wear something comfortable from the closet.
Joon-young! Ramen's ready.
Joon-young!
You didn't answer when I called you.
- Ramen's ready, come out and eat. - OK, I'll be right out.
This was reported that night. I hope this helps.
(I saw a male student run out of the building then ran to the backyard.)
So what's your plan?
Let's have the witness face the audience.
The jury should be made up of 8 or 9 members.
Refer to page 107 of "The History of Criminal Cases in Court."
There's a typo on the third page of the school trial proposal.
Congratulations on the trial.
Why...
Why to me?
Ah, you're here!
Hello, Seo-yeon!
I know Seo-yeon doesn't like to wait around, so let's cut to the chase.
You said you wanted to investigate on Jeong-guk Watchman, right?
Yes, and?
Have you found out who it is?
Why, all of a sudden?
You were so upset with me that I wanted to, just a while ago.
I have a reason to find out now.
A reason...
I'll help you if I can understand that reason.
Jeong-guk Watchman is the one who suggested the school trial to me.
We planned the whole thing together.
I never suspected him, since he's been a good friend for a long time.
He helped me and comforted me whenever I needed him to.
I had been nothing but grateful for him.
But now that I think about it...
He's been making me move in the direction he wanted me to go.
That's natural, he's...
Reporter Park?
You already know?
You know who he is!
Seo-yeon.
I'll tell you this, consider it a tip.
Don't trust Jeong-guk Watchman too much.
I didn't know Han Ji-hoon even planned the trial to begin with.
I knew we were onto something.
He planned it and he even starred in it! Of course he'd be great in it.
So...
Who do you think is his target?
If he's that determined to find out about Lee So-woo's death...
I don't think he's lying about it.
But he's not targeting Choi Woo-hyuk.
Who's he closing in on?
I think...
It's the school.
It's just a hunch.
He brought up how the Committee was unfair.
If Han Ji-hoon is going against Jeong-guk High School,
does that mean Mr. Han is also...
Probably not, right? It's his own father!
Big news!
The principal is back.
- Liar! - I saw him with my own eyes!
So he's back at his post?
Back? Who's back?
The principal.
Seo-yeon.
Can I get a moment?
(Agreement to disband a club)
Just fill it out, don't waste time.
- What is this? - Can't you read?
It's an agreement to disband your trial club.
Yes, we can see that. But why do we need to sign this?
Are you always that rude? Or are you trying to start something with me?
Ma'am.
Oh, you again?
OK, fine.
I'm taking off a point each for whoever speaks from now on, with my authority.
What?
Choi Seung-hyun.
- What is happening? - Lee Yoo-jin.
You're all suspended starting today.
You're suspended everyday until you sign this agreement.
You understand?
Suspension for one week leads to expulsion, no questions asked.
Based on what?
Look at page 107.
"Those who caused a serious damage to the school and
those who led an unauthorized group action."
Please give a specific example.
What serious damage did we cause and
what unauthorized group action did we take?
Just wait a week. I'll write it in the expulsion notice.
Think carefully.
The school has no choice to act according to policy if you keep being stubborn.
Also remember that a serious disciplinary action like suspension remains in your
school record forever.
(Notice: The main students involved in the school
trial have violated school policy, thus are suspended for 1 day.
I've never seen a suspension notice before.
Doesn't it stay in your record? How shocking!
How sad!
What is it?
Are they crazy?
What kind of a school just suspends students for no good reason?
Yes, call your mom and tell her to get over here!
I'm calling my college counselor.
Yes, I have an issue with my school record.
Are we... Really going to be expelled?
Doesn't need to go that far, a suspension is bad enough!
All of our volunteer works mean nothing when we get a suspension record!
This is so frustrating!
I don't care.
I won't quit.
No.
You all need to think more carefully.
Of course I don't want to listen to them, this is completely upsetting.
But this can make our lives harder for the next few years.
Let's think about it at home.
We need a plan.
Seo-yeon!
Teacher!
- Hello! - How have you been?
I've been well! How are you?
You made this into the club room?
It was a storage space.
Took us a while to get it cleaned up.
I'm sure it was worth it.
Please take a seat.
I heard you were traveling overseas.
You're back?
Yes, back for good, I arrived a couple of weeks ago.
I work at a nearby art school now.
You must've been busy.
I have been.
Busy enough that I didn't even know what happened to So-woo.
Seo-yeon.
I heard about the trial.
You're the prosecutor?
Yes.
Can I testify?
You?
Yes.
I don't...
Believe So-woo killed himself.
Teacher.
If I disappear one day...
What will you do?
They're telling me to leave this school.
Says who?
What are you talking about?
Suspension?
Oh my!
They can't just suspend students like that, especially in this day and time!
To the students who are about to go into college?
Who do they think they are?
Don't worry, I'll look into it and figure it out.
No.
Just leave it.
The trial is what's important right now.
I don't want it to be postponed for things like this.
Seo-yeon!
How can you...
I mean, that student...
You know his alibi now, right?
Isn't that the end of Th trial then?
Just because Choi Woo-hyuk is found to be innocent,
it doesn't mean we know what exactly happened that night.
There are too many things we still do not know yet,
and someone's hiding something.
But now, the trial is the only chance we have to find out what it is!
I understand that there still are lingering doubts in the Lee So-woo incident.
But it doesn't have to be the school trial to find out more about them.
Then what else?
People already forgot about the incident.
Just when it was on TV,
just when Choi Woo-hyuk's house burned down,
and when Joo-ri posted the video...
That's all there was.
We're the only ones who still want to know why So-woo had to die.
If I give up...
The Lee So-woo incident will just be buried under the rug.
Is that OK with you?
We'll just call it a suicide and forget it? Is that comforting?
I hope at least you can understand.
I'm scared, too.
I know the suspension record is going to cause trouble later.
I feel bad for the kids who got involved in the trial because of me, too.
But still...
The trial must go on.
The rest of the story must be told!
No matter how much I think about it,
this is the right thing to do.
Hello?
Oh, yes. Hello. Take a seat!
Want something to drink?
Oh, I'm OK.
So... You've been suspended?
Yes.
Starting today.
Even if that doesn't lead to expulsion,
it's detrimental to have that kind of record before going to college.
I'm more worried about the other kids.
Yes, I feel bad for them too.
They met a wrong friend.
I mean, not you.
I'm talking about Han Ji-hoon from Jeong-guk Arts School.
What about him?
You didn't know?
His father gave the order to suspend you guys!
Wow, you really had no idea!
Then...
He kept it a secret this whole time?
Please explain in more detail.
Who's Han Ji-hoon's dad?
He's the head of the legal department in Jeong-guk Foundation.
He's notorious!
He had a hand in the Lee So-woo incident, too.
What is it? You came all the way to my house?
You haven't heard?
We might be expelled from school.
What?
We got suspended from school today.
They're calling it a suspension but it's a threat, since if we refuse
to leave the club, we're expelled.
They must give a reason!
We caused damage to school and committed an unauthorized group activity.
I compared it to the school policy book we received in the beginning, and it's
a new policy they made up.
I think they made it because of us.
Someone did.
I don't understand.
There are six students in the club.
Isn't that absurd?
My parents, and other kids' parents too, will not just sit still.
This might be on the news, too!
I have no idea why the school is wanting us to quit the trial, at such great risks!
You...
You know?
You know why the school's being this way?
I don't know.
- What will you do? - I'm more curious about your thoughts.
You haven't heard anything from your school?
I go to a different school.
But they're by the same foundation.
I'm the prosecutor and you're the defense counsel.
How's it that you're totally fine?
Isn't it odd that nothing ever happens to you?
If you really have no idea, then that's just too bad.
I'll get going.
Ko Seo-yeon.
The trial...
You'll continue it?
Even if it's by myself, I won't quit.
Suspension...
I heard about that.
Suspension...
I heard about that.
I didn't know you'd be that cheap.
That was internally decided by Jeong-guk High School.
Then can you make them withdraw it?
You have the power.
Ji-hoon, there's no use in whining.
Just because they're your friends,
that doesn't mean I can just tell the school what to do based on my
personal feelings.
If it's not personal, then how is it I'm the only one who's not punished?
How come I'm the only who's not suspended?
We were in the same club.
We were in the same trial.
This is...
Jeong-guk High School's policy. Not your school.
If they get expelled,
I'm going to drop out, too.
If they did something wrong, I should be punished, too.
If you don't sign for me to drop out of school,
I won't go to school until I am expelled according to policy.
Or,
I can just get in trouble big time.
You'll never be expelled.
Then...
Should I reveal my past?
Will they let me come to school if they knew that I'm the son of a murderer?
Isn't that what you're afraid of the most?
To see me get hurt.
How can you say such a thing?
This is...
To protect you!
Don't you understand?
It's to protect me?
Or is it...
To protect yourself?
What do you mean?
You think...
So-woo didn't tell me anything?
You think I don't know anything?
Han Ji-hoon.
I...
I'm going through the trial no matter what happens.
Ji-hoon.
Your dad...
He's got a secret.
You want to know?
You really had no idea?
He's kept it a secret this whole time?
Do you think that was my only lie?
By any chance...
Do you know anything about Han Ji-hoon?
(Notice: The students involved in the trial are
suspended for 2 days according to school policy.)
Hello.
You can sit down.
It's OK, go on.
I feel terrible about this.
I tried to stop your being suspended at all costs.
You're suspended because of us, too.
We heard.
But there's an upside to this.
I got to sleep in after the suspension, and check out my skin!
So clean!
You're happy for your skin when you sacrificed your future?
Don't be so harsh.
Find strength by looking at the positive side.
What will you do with the club?
Yes.
I'll keep going.
It's OK, I understand.
What you want and the reality are two different things.
You can speak freely.
OK, fine.
I'll have to quit.
My grades are already mediocre.
At least my school record needs to be clean.
I'm so sorry.
No, it's OK.
You made a good decision.
I have to quit, too.
My mom said she'll move me to a new school if I continued.
I'd rather give up the trial if I have to leave you guys.
I'll continue.
Me too.
Kim Min-seok. How about you?
Do I have any choice? How can there be a trial without a judge?
Do you think I'm doing this for fun?
You just make your claim and examine the witnesses, a few objections, and
that's it.
But I mediate both of your claims and listen to every opinion carefully.
I control the audience, tell them to be silent.
I make this trial happen,
and am in charge of it.
There is no replacement for me.
So I can't quit.
Of course, it'll be a flaw in my perfect school record.
But I have ways to overcome it.
So just make sure you prepare well for the fourth session.
Then we have two prosecutors and two defense counsels, and one judge.
We'll start over this way.
You'll at least watch, right?
If you skip volunteer study class, it's five points deduction from now.
That's OK. I can hear your cheers from your classroom, you're loud enough.
Of course! I'll show you what human vuvuzela is!
I’ll be the president of the trial club's fan club!
What do you want to eat?
Tell me what you feel like.
Spring rolls!
I want funnel cakes.
A sausage soup!
You're quitting too, you don't get to eat.
(The last trial session: 11 AM, Auditorium)
That male student...
We have no more evidence and there's no witness.
What can we possibly find out about him in trial?
We have to try until the end.
It's our last chance.
Seo-yeon!
They want you in the principal's office.
The principal's office?
Hey, don't worry! We're already suspended!
Come in.
How about the principal?
No.
I asked for you today.
Have a seat.
My name is Han Kyung-hoon, the head of the legal department of
Jeong-guk foundation.
(Solomon's Perjury)